Small-town theatre critic pans community production with 4.5 star review - The Beaverton

Small-town theatre critic pans community production with 4.5 star review

GUELPH – Local Gregory Stephens held nothing back reviewing a local production of Tennessee Williams’s “Cat on a Hot Tin Roof,” issuing a lowly 4.5 out of 5 stars.

Unlike his previous 67 reviews praising every community performance at the Old Fire Hall Theatre, Stephens issued a rare mention of what could be considered as constructive criticism in the local .

“What does he mean ‘there were a few stumbles in an otherwise outstanding performance?’” said Harold McPherson, who played Brick, but forgot most of his lines. “I knew this prick had it out for me ever since I was Biff in ‘Death of a Salesman.’ He probably wanted to play my part, but he was just talentless hack.”

54-year-old Alice Schiff, who played Big Mama using an Australian accent instead of a Southern American one, also condemned the critic’s rebuke.

“I’m never talking to Greg at the grocery store again,” said Schiff, a long time performer at the Old Fire Hall Theatre. “To him, it’s like we murdered a nun on stage and called it art. What is wrong with that man?”

Despite Stephens’ overwhelmingly positive assessment as a ‘must see,’ the entire cast and crew believed the single critique was needlessly unfair.

“Oh sure, [Stephens] will go after every technical detail, but he just doesn’t get that it was a reinterpretation when the set collapsed on Gooper knocking him out cold that one time,” said Director Allan Peterson, describing an awkward point in the performance which the carefully omits.

Don't forget to watch all new episodes of The Beaverton TV Show Tuesdays at 10 on CTV! Get FREE tickets to a taping here.